Advertise on ChoralNet 
ChoralNet logo
The mission of the ACDA is to inspire excellence in choral music through education, performance, composition, and advocacy.

English: Most common English diction problems



Dear Colleagues,

Herein is contained the various responses that I have received from my
query about common English diction problems. I did not receive any
responses concerning web sites. Thanks for all your assistance. You have
been very helpful.

P. Kevin Suiter, D.M.A.
Music Program Coordinator
Appalachian Bible College
Bradley WV 28642
(304)877-6428, ext. 3255
ksuiter(a)abc.edu

ORIGINAL POST

What are some of the most common English diction problems that you find
yourself correcting (recorrecting?) in rehearsals? Please share the
problem and your recommended solution. I'll compile a list and post if
there is interest.

RESPONSES

Our wonderful vowel errrr.
For over eight I've been working to rid a church choir of this, yet with
every new text, it sounds as if I'm confronting a band of pirates.
ARRRGH!
Ryc Williamson
Aloha Oregon
______________

That's easy! It's when my choir pronounces "angels" as "an-JELLS" instead
of with a schwa. The difficult occurs when the second syllable of "angels"
must receive a full beat.

Ruth McKendree Treen
Chatham, Massachusetts
_________________

I am always excising the hard "r".

I also struggle with the volume of the voiced consonants "d" and "g". I
sometimes try to move the placement of these to get them to pop a little.

Vowels...
I also need to work with my (mostly older) choir on moving quickly to the
vowel, especially where there are slow developing blends.
I work from time to time on singing on the front of the diphthong
(we are in Chicago)

Ray Klemchuk
______________

in brief:
too-strong retroflex "r" (to choir: leave off the "r" or flip it or roll
it,
depending on the style and origin of the piece)
"oo" that sounds like "ewww" (as in "Yucky!") (to choir: sing "oo" as in
"moon"; round the lips as if you're using a large straw)
voiced consonants that are not pitched, so they sound unvoiced (i.e. "love"
becomes "luff")
(fix this with demonstration and repetition)

I'm sure these problems vary from region to region, and that there are also
some common problems.

Kirin Nielsen
nielsenk(a)ripon.edu
_____________

Greetings, Kevin. My most common English diction problems are
1. The I and A diphthongs--teaching the students to sing the first
sound of the diphthong. I use examples of how not to do it. I tell my
students that if they recorded me saying a long "I" sound, it would
sound like AAAAAAAAHHHHHEEEEE. A long A sound would be EEEEHHHHEEEE. I
explain that going to the second part of the diphthong would make them
sound like some country-western singers. Then they understand what I am
talking about. We talk about Professor Henry Higgins in "My Fair Lady"
trying to change speech patterns of Eliza Doolittle.
2. Not putting ending consonants on words. So I pronounce the
text--overemphasizing the ending consonants and they have to repeat it
back to me exactly as I spoke it.
3. Singing UH instead of AH. I created the "Land of Ah's" poster
featuring "Dorothy and the gang"--on the yellow bricks we write the
words such as WAS, WHAT, THE, OF, LOVE, UPON, MOTHER, etc. So there's
the visual approach. Then I also pronounce the words like above and
they have to repeat it back to me. I recite the text with great
dramatic flair and the students like to repeat it back to me with great
dramatic flair. I also have a "Hot Tip" bulletin board featuring:
Never sing an UH unless you are substituting it for an ER like in RIVER,
EVER, FOREVER, EARTH, etc. and we periodically add new words to the hot
tips board.

-Denise Baccadutre
Moriarty High School Choral Director
Moriarty, New Mexico
________________

My diction pet peeves:
- "let you" and other words ending with "t" followed by you or your
pronounced like "leh-choo" - it sounds like a sneeze in the middle of your
phrase!
- "our" pronounced like the pirate's "arrr"! - please, sing it more like
"hour"!

katie

_________________

any diphthong which includes the sustained "ah"
dmccorm(a)erols.com
__________________

Mr. Suiter --

My most common problems are placement of final consonants (t, d, p, and s)
and 'hissing' [s]'s in words like "Christmas."

Craig C. Hawkins
___________________

Kevin,

I think this will depend on the language and social background of your
students (although not quite as much as with vowels). With US students I
often have a problem with the hard r sound. With English students, never.
With students from East coast US and English students whose parents speak
with what we call BBC english, a dropped t or h is less common.

In general, the most common problems tend to do with elision of final
consonants onto initial vowels. This can be taught quickly through
example:

It's not - It's snot usually raises a laugh and the kids always remember
it.

Gladly the cross I'd bear - Gladly the cross-eyed bear also works and a
littl more wholesome.

Getting the kids to find examples in the text where this could happen is
always interesting. You would think it was straight forward until you hear
some of the responses.

Paul Stanley
Choir and Assistant Band Director
Hong Kong International School
Middle School
_________________

Off the top of my head (which is rather flat! LOL!), there's:

beautiful (byoo tee ful rather than byoo tih ful)

highest (high yest rather than high est)

Any word ending in "y" such as "Glory" (glo ree rather than glo rih)

Any word ending in "ing" such as "living" (usually sounds like a "y"

"Praise" usually sounds like "raise"

"Israel" (Iz rye el or Iss ray el versus Iz ray el)

To correct these things, I point them out, demonstrate, have them say the
word both ways, then sing it both ways so they can both hear and feel the
difference, then go with the correct way. I also use a tape recorder and
have them listen to a phrase or section and tell me what's "wrong."

Many Blessings!

Craig D. Collins
Director of Music Ministry
Mt. Zion United Methodist Church
19600 Zion Street
Cornelius, NC 28031
ccollins(a)mtzionumc.net




on December 7, 2005 10:00pm
Of course, I have encountered all of the problems mentioned already. My unending misson with my singers is, and has been for decades, to create an intense legato line, wherein I hear unified vowels, but even more importantly, I hear every part of every syllable - especially consonants - without a break in energy, and at the correct time. I am a firm believer that this sound, which I call "Choral Speak" to my singers, can solve so many problems, e.g., intonation and precision. However, I have never been able to convince my groups to put out the energy required to produce this result on an ongoing basis. I just trained a chorus for our local productioin of the Messiah, and acheived Choral Speak for several phrases in a couple of rehearsals. Alas, when we got together with the orchestra, it virtually disappeared. I have not yet given up, because I have heard the choirs of some directors do it ... e.g., Shaw, Archibeque, etc. Not only can I understand the text these ensembles sing, but I receive the emotional content of the poetry as well. Surely, this is an admirable goal. So, I wish for all of you, where it is needed, that laser-beam legato phrase, with no cessation of sound, long vowels, short but crisp and precisely placed consonants, and the emission of musical meaning. I shall probably go to my grave mumbling, "Choral Speak, give me Choral Speak!!!"