EnsembleManager 1
Advertise on ChoralNet 
ChoralNet logo

Oral Surgery

Friends...I have a former voice student who has been advised to get some oral work done, which also involves getting a partial plate in the roof of his mouth. His question is "Will the plate in the roof of his mouth (titanium) affect the sound production of my voice?"
 
Thanks for all who may have any insight into this!
 
Craig 
Replies (2): Threaded | Chronological
on October 6, 2009 4:52pm
Craig,
 
Any oral surgery will affect vocal production. Sometimes it's a good thing. I have a dear friend who had her jaw broken and realigned to fix a bad underbite when we were in high school. After surgery (which was no picnic), it was much easier for her to drop her jaw and she now has a bachelor's and master's in vocal performace and is a successful singer.  For her, surgery was a godsend and helped her vocal production.
 
As for the titanium plate, I would think the big consideration would be how tall (for lack of a better word) the plate is and how much closer  it will bring the palate to the tongue. If it is a significant change, enunciation will certainly be more difficult. If it is a plate that goes in the front half of the roof of the mouth only, I would think that it might be like when an adolescent gets "spacers" put on behind back front teeth with their braces. This definitely creates problems with enunciation with the middle school kids with braces I've been teaching for the last 20 years. I'm no doctor, but putting something int he roof of the mouth seems like it would create problems unless it is is fixing an actual deformity of the palate.  I'll be interested to see what others think!
 
Mary Jane Phillips
on October 7, 2009 9:43pm
I expect that a metal plate in the hard palate area would not impact actual sound production as much as it would impact the sensations (internal feedback) of singing. This might take some time to get used to, like the rest of new oral structures & sensations this person is facing!
 
HOWEVER I would strongly recommend consulting with a physician who truly knows the needs of singers; a phone call from the singer to Dr. Sataloff in Philadelphia would not be unreasonable. This would not be a formal "2nd opinion" —unless Sataloff could refer to an oral surgeon who also knows singers— but just a request for info/context/reassurance. If Denver is closer, call the National Center for Voice and Speech (www.ncvs.org) and just ask if one of the clinical staff can answer the singer's questions.
 
best wishes -
 
Joanna Cazden
speech pathologist & singing voice specialist
  • You must log in or register to be able to reply to this message.