Bachelor of Music in choral conducting...does it exist?Date: November 12, 2009
Dear conductors,
I am currently researching music education degrees at various institutions around the country. The question arose: is there such a thing as a BM in choral conducting (not a MusEd degree)?
The closest I could come up with was Belhaven College's degree in Vocal Pedagogy and Choral Conducting. Does anyone know of other programs?
Sincerely,
Julie Parsons
University of Washington Replies (11): Threaded | Chronological
Tom Tropp on November 12, 2009 12:24pm
We've had several students at Northwestern University complete ad hoc majors in conducting in the past couple years. Honestly, though, I don't understand why a student interested in conducting would not complete an ed major. No amount of training comes CLOSE to what you learn in three to five years of high school teaching.
on November 12, 2009 12:53pm
Dear Ms. Parsons:
Contact the Chapman University School of Music in
Orange, CA.
Cordially,
Thomas Sheets, D.M.A.
on November 12, 2009 2:12pm
Hi, Julie. I think you'll find that it isn't a "normal" degree for an undergraduate, but as Tom said, there are schools where you can sort of build your own degree program (and others, of course, where you cannot). We used to have a designed option degree here, but it has been phased out.
But there's always an option for someone willing to think outside the box, who is a self-starter and who is willing to build your own program WITHIN a conventional degree like vocal performance. Ask for and sign up for advanced private conducting study after you complete the introductory courses. Find a position where you can help out as an Assistant Conductor. Put together your own Junior and Senior conducting recitals, and learn to work with and to lead not just singers but instrumentalists as well. After all, the people skills and musical skills it will take to do those things are exactly the skills you'll need as a conductor out in the Real World!
The usual assumption, and the assumption that drives the degree programs at most colleges and universities, is that the undergraduate years are the time to learn the basics, and that includes the VERY basics of conducting, score study, history and literature. There's a reason for that mind set, since most faculty have been through it and understand how MUCH you need to learn about music in general and not just about conducting in particular, whether you presently know it (or agree with it) or not.
I don't necessarily agree with Tom that a music ed degree is the BEST prepraration for someone seriously interested in conducting, although it is a degree that's more likely to get you a job, and you WILL learn a lot on that job, just as he says. Whether what you learn is what you will need to become a professional conductor is a different question. (And if you aren't careful you can learn some awfully BAD conducting habits that will only have to be discarded later!) At most schools even the masters programs are skewed toward education or church jobs. That was certainly the case at Indiana back in the '70s when I did my graduate work, and that's why I stepped outside the box and petitioned for permission to take the doctoral choral conducting and score study courses for my masters (twice as many courses and twice as much work, but I wouldn't trade them for ANYTHING!).
All the best, Julie, and I hope you find what you're looking for.
John
on November 12, 2009 3:55pm
There are a good number of Canadian choral conductors who have benefited from such an undergraduate program at either of the two Mennonite colleges in Winnipeg (now combined to form Canadian Mennonite University). I know of at least a dozen who are now successfully engaged in choral careers who had their initial start in this program. The capping exercise in each case was a full-fledged choral recital. Only 1 or 2 students were enrolled at any one time in these programs, so it was possible to organize the resources needed for these recitals. Mention should be made of the two choral professors at the time, William Baerg (Concord College) and George Wiebe (Canadian Mennonite Bible College), who were instrumental in seeing these programs flourish. To my knowledge this undergraduate choral conducting program still exists, under the direction of Rudy Schellenberg and Janet Brenneman.
Len Ratzlaff
University of Alberta
on November 13, 2009 9:52am
I know when I was doing undergrad I would have loved a BM in Choral Conducting. I didn't want a MusEd degree because I wanted to go into church music and be a choral director for churches. My emphasis has somewhat changed since then, but I still wish I would have had more opportunity in college to learn about choral conducting.
on November 13, 2009 11:09am
Hi, Joshua, and please forgive a brief addendum to my pervious post.
How much instructions in conducting is actually available at most schools? By that I mean hands-on classes in hand-waving, courses devoted to literature and score study, and most importantly podium time?
Given that every school is different, the large majority would probably be one semester at minimum (which may not differentiate between choral and instrumental, and may emphasize either band or orchestra more than choir), and probably 2 semesters at most.
Will that teach you to be an effective conductor? NO WAY! It will just give you the basics, but you'll actually learn to conduct only after you get in front of a chorus. I started doing that in high school, learned the basics (and rather more than the basics) from my Dad, and didn't learn all that much more in college classes except how to follow a recording! Actually college is too LATE to start from the beginning.
Then who are you going to conduct? College ensembles all have their own schedules and preparations and concerts, and you'd be lucky if they could devote one day per semester to student conducting. So you would have to be in a very large Music Department or School of Music where there are a LOT of choral ensembles and there were opportunities for student assistants. That was the case at Indiana in the '70s, where EVERY conducting class, including undergrad classes, had its own chorus, with a lot of keyboard players and without ideal balance, but at least singers to work with.
But a really large Music Department or School of Music is going to be smart enough to teach the basics in their undergrad classes, and save the serious, in-depth score study and conducting techniques for their Masters and Doctoral courses, so you still can't win! Not to say that there might be schools that DO have a specialized program with an undergrad conducting major (but not necessarily CHORAL conducting), but you'll have to search those schools out and not expect that kind of training in your average music department.
All the best,
John
on November 13, 2009 12:27pm
Hi Julie,
On the website for Mannes College at the New School in NYC, choral conducting is listed as one of the BM degree fields of study. I don't have any information about their program. Sorry. Here is the link.
Alice Cavanaugh
Suffolk Community College, NY
on November 13, 2009 12:37pm
Hi Julie: A few places -- Westminster Choir College at Ryder University, NJ.; California Institute of the Arts, Valencia, CA; Julliard School, NYC; Mannes (mentioned before); SUNY (State University of New York), Purchase, NY.; Peabody School, Tennessee; Indiana Univeristy, Bloomington, IN and many others, I am sure. -- Follow your dreams. Music Ed is useful if you intend to be in education and in a school. if it is for professional reasons, get to the training ASAP.
Corltandt S. Bender
San Carlos, CA
on November 15, 2009 6:57pm
Julie,
USC is now offering a BA in Choral Music Degree. Our intent was not to go the music education route - but rather a degree which focuses on a student's particular interest outside of choral music. A student for instance may combine this with a any other interest, whether Biology, marketing and advertising, arts administration, sacred music including Jewish Studies to create a degree which is specific to their interest. A terrific plan for those not necessarily interested in just one facet of music. In addition they may also chose to complete a fifth year of work and receive not only a California teaching certificate but also a Masters degree in Music.
Jo-Michael Scheibe, DMA
Chair and Professor
Flora L. Thornton School of Music
Department of Choral and Sacred Music
on January 12, 2010 12:13pm
Hi Julie,
I'm currently a student at St Olaf finishing a BA General Music degree, but I've been able to work through the conducting sequence here. I think what you'll find at most schools is that you can't get a Conducting degree persay, but you can easily take the courses that give you the experience needed. Here at Olaf there are 3 semesters of actual conducting classes, culminating in an Advanced Conducting project where you rehearse a choir of peers for 6 weeks and put on a recital with your classmates at the end of the project. There are also several courses in literature and pedagogy that aren't purely music education based, but give you practical information regarding rehearsal and repetoire. I don't know how many undergraduate programs out there offer as in depth a conducting/rehearsal practices sequence, but i'm sure they exist. Hope that helps
Bryce Kennedy
St. Olaf College
on January 12, 2010 3:20pm
To follow up what Bryce said, it is possible to take 4 semesters of conducting at St. Olaf. I graduated in 2003 with a music ed major and took 3 semesters of choral conducting plus one semester of instrumental conducting. This semester, I will finish my masters in choral conducting at Colorado State University. I found my training at St. Olaf to be invaluable. Much of the material covered in the third semester of choral conducting was graduate level material.
Austen
|