Dress rehearsals
Advertise on ChoralNet 
ChoralNet logo

Need assistance on choosing piano with player system...

I wrote last year about the new building we are moving into, and things have been very interesting ever since.  Most of the money that we were supposed to receive disappeared due to the economy - something about it being based on the bonds that were issued.  However, I have just gotten approval to purchase a grand piano for the choir room, which I am estatic about - Up to this time, we have been accompanying the choirs with a Roland HPi-5 - both for rehearsal and performances.

We have a LOT going on in the program - 6 curricular choirs, plus extracurricular groups, but I am the only director, with no accompanist.  Because of this, it's important to me that we have some sort of "player" system.  I often have used my laptop hooked up to the Roland to play parts off of Sibelius.  I used to use a Yamaha disklavier to accompany myself in undergrad and grad school, and am hoping to do the same for the choirs here.

So here are my two choices that I have been offered from two different vendors.

1. Yamaha 5'3" DGC1M4PE (Piano with Mark IV Dislavier), with piano dolly & cover - $26,000

2. Boston 6'4" GP193 with Pianodisc system, with dolly & cover - $26,500

I'm not familiar at all with Boston pianos, though I know that they're designed by Steinway and manufactured in a Kawai plant.  I will be going to look at the Boston this week, and have played the Yamaha - the Yamaha is much darker toned than I remember them being...

Your thoughts?
 
Replies (2): Threaded | Chronological
on December 14, 2009 4:07am
Hi, Paul.  My own question is whether you will be able to move the grand easily from your rehearsal room to your performance venue.  If so, and if you have that kind of budget, I might suggest that you get the best PIANO you can get without worrying about its having built-in electronic gadgets.  I assume that you'll still have the Roland, right?  And you can continue to use it for playback?  (Although I'm not a big fan of prerecorded accompaniments in any form, but of course that's a different discussion!)
 
Since I'm not a pianist, I can't speak to particular instruments.  I haven't been very impressed with the various Yamahas, at least not compared with real Steinways, although a few of our faculty members do use a Diskclavier, and I'm not familiar with "Boston" at all.  But the larger a grand you can get, the more it will sound like a real piano.  You ust can't beat those long bass strings!
 
All the best,
 
John
 
 
on December 14, 2009 3:05pm
If you use Sibelius VI to play your piano accompaniments I don't believe you would need to use a piano at all.  The piano sounds in Sib VI are better than many keyboards.  My $.02:  Upgrade to Sib VI and spend the rest of they money on a real piano.

Your description of what happened to the bond money would be impossible in my state.  It would be interesting if you could see an accounting of that money without stirring things up too much.  On the other hand, I'm thining that you have an excellent understanding of this and just used the word "disappeared" to save a lot of typing.
 
Rob Reck
reckeuph(a)sbcglobal.net
http://members.sibeliusmusic.com/robreck
 
 
  • You must log in or register to be able to reply to this message.