Alfred Music Publishing
Advertise on ChoralNet 
ChoralNet logo

New hymnal search

My church is starting the process of buying a new hymnal.  We currently use the old Pilgrim Hymnal, but have moved to a more blended service with a contemporary bent. Congregational singing has become more frequent in our service, and much better also!  I am seeking suggestions, recommendations for a possible purchase.  Also, suggestions on evaluation forms would be welcome.
 
Michael S. Wade
First Congregational UCC, Elkhart, In
Replies (6): Threaded | Chronological
on May 24, 2010 6:46pm
 
the entire site has some useful information for churches launching to a blended worship style. There is a PDF available on the site, too, for evaluating songs.
 
hope this helps
 
-Cecil Rigby
Liberty, SC
on May 25, 2010 5:52am
I would look seriously at Lifeway's Baptist Hymnal/Worship Hymnal (http://www.lifeway.com/product/005085896/?cs=1). It takes a blended approach in it's song selection. The selling point for me, though, is that there are all sorts of additional resources available--praise team charts, orchestrations, piano accompaniments, etc. I haven't spent a lot of time with it, but it looks promising.
 
Another thing to consider is buying a hymnal that contains all the hymn chestnuts that you'll need (Hope's Worship & Rejoice, or your denomination's hymnal might be good choices), and then using projection or your bulletin (combined with a CCLI license) for more contemporary songs. This gives you something dependable in your pew rack for funerals, Thanksgiving, etc, while giving you a great deal of flexibility with newer songs which tend to rotate in and out of a church's repertoire more quickly.
 
Peace,
 
Greg
on May 25, 2010 6:44am
My UCC congregation got the New Century Hymnal several years ago, and has been very happy with it. Despite the feeling that some of  the inclusive language modifications are a bit over-worked, the thing that they like the most is the variety of styles and large number of hymns. Modern hymns and hymn tunes, Gospel songs, Spanish songs, and more of their favorite traditional hymns than the Pilgrim Hymnal ever had allows us a lot of ways to program a service.
 
It is also remarkably free of the kind of songs some of my parishioners refer to as the "I wish Jesus was my boyfriend" or "God, I have been so bad but you make me feel really, really good" kind of songs that seem to them to be too big a part of "praise music" services.
 
Reginald Unterseher
on May 25, 2010 6:46am
Check out the Celebrating Grace Hymnal - just published and very balanced.
 
 
Thomas Coker
South Main Baptist, Houston
on May 25, 2010 12:31pm
Look at the Celebration Hymnal from Word Music.Edited by Tom Fettke, it's pretty much an even balance of traditional hymns and contemporary praise and worship music, and even has some options for transitioning from a praise chorus into a hymn for a truly blended experience.
on May 25, 2010 2:45pm
If part of your worship style includes church orchestra, the Celebration Hymnal also has a set of books with instrumental arrangements for each hymn.  They are written for full orchestra but can be used with less than full instrumentation.
  • You must log in or register to be able to reply to this message.