Frog in the Throat -- Amateur SingerDate: August 3, 2010
I sang in a barbershop quartet, and in the high school chorus. The music teacher took a special interest in the four of us that were in the quartet and gave us some extra singing instruction after school. That was the end of anything that could have been called my "formal training". That was 45 years ago.
A number of years ago I was asked to join the church choir. I was thrilled. Many people say I have a pretty good voice, so I guess I do. We have a Psalm as part of our service each Sunday. Our church music director decided some time ago to chant the Psalm, as opposed to just reading it. We used to trade the chanting of the Psalm from person to person in the choir, until, at one point, I was asked to sing the Psalm every Sunday. I was honored to do this. So, now I am the "Lone Cantor". I consider this to be a great honor. The chant for the Psalm is a simple eight note progression that repeats every two versus. Our choir does not meet on a regular basis for rehearsals during the summer months. Instead, our music director has some of us do solos, or small group hymns, as anthems during this time. Here is the question: last Sunday I was scheduled to chant the Psalm, as usual, and also sing "the Lord's Prayer" by Malotte as a solo. This is not a difficult piece, and can be done with power and grace. The music director and I practiced it before the service started. It went very well. Towards the beginning of the service I chanted the Psalm. Towards the end of this, I noticed that my voice was doing that squeaking and croaking thing. I forced myself to get to the end. The solo started well, but as we passed the middle, and approached the end I could again hear my voice croaking. I had to strive mightily to make it to the finish. This was extremely embarrassing for me, because this doesn't usually happen. I have sung solos in church before, and while they haven't been world-class, they have at least been pretty decent. It was a relatively hot, and extremely humid Sunday. Our church doesn't have A/C. What should I have done to prevent this voice problem? My son-in-law used to play guitar in a rock 'n roll band. I mentioned my problem to him and he said that the lead singer used to gargle with some mixture of honey or something before each performance so that he could scream his way to the end without losing his voice. Is there something that I could treat my throat with that would help prevent this croaking? I am willing to take a few voice lessons if I could find someone who I considered to be reasonably competent to help me. I'm not looking to be a professional singer, just do a better job on Sundays. Is this worth doing? Any other suggestions? Thank you in advance for your help. Replies (8): Threaded | Chronological
Doreen Simmons on August 4, 2010 3:00am
Has anything changed in the airconditioning of your church, or anything else that affects the air itself? If this is a new problem for you, before you try anything heroic, you might try a very old trick: shortly before singing, take a very small spoonful of Vaseline, slowly suck it and swallow it. It will put a thin lining on your throat. But don't increase the amount as it may have embarrassing effects on your digestive system. Good luck!
on August 4, 2010 5:57am
HI Ken,
Sometimes the best of us get "frogs in the throat" because of weather, dust, or who knows what. The temperature/humidity in the church could have been a factor. But it doesn't have to stop you. Since your voice is unique to you, prescriptions from long distance without hearing and seeing you sing wouldn't be much help. I would encourage you to take a few voice lessons, so that you can learn ways to get past your difficulty using good vocal technique. Keep at it!
Best wishes,
Meagan Smith
on August 4, 2010 9:27am
Did you have a proper rest/sleep prior to going to church? It is always advisable to do a little vocal warm up prior to the begining of the service.
on August 4, 2010 11:12am
Ken: Obviously we can't diagnose your problem at long distance, but my question would be whether it's continuing to be a problem or whether it was a one-time thing?
It could be anything from a serious medical problem to your temporary personal health to, as others have asked, a matter of air conditioning. When my vocal/instrumental quartet was entertaning in night clubs back in the early '60s, we would go from hot and muggy weather outside to very chill air conditioning inside, and the predictable result was that we started losing our voices from the top down: first our top tenor, then our lead, then me. (Basses never lose their voices!!!)
Or, right now something in Western Virginia must be blooming, because I've been sneezing and dripping like crazy, although an air cleaner seems to be helping.
But if it continues, get thee to a good throat doctor who can peer down your throat and see what's happening with your vocal folds. One possibility, if you've been abusing your voice at all, would be vocal nodes, which are a SYMPTOM of a problem, not the problem itself, but might call for some voice therapy. That probably isn't the case, unless you've been singing with your son-in-law in a rock band, but doctors always want to rule out the worst possibilities first.
And if it isn't any of the above, and if (as it seems) you haven't studied voice seriously at any point in your career, yes, by all means track down a good voice teacher, someone who can identify and help you lose any bad vocal habits you may have fallen into. That's something that does happen to folks who have a really nice natural voice, but don't understand how it works or how to fix it if problems arise.
Anything that coats your throat is questionable, whether it's tea with honey in it or valeline (NOT for internal consumption!). I really wouldn't try any of those home remedies without consulting a doctor first.
All the best,
John
on September 5, 2010 11:53am
I agree with John, its really not possible to diagnose a problem from far away. if it is a one time thing, I would look at the circumstances surrounding the event. Make sure you are well rested, drinking plenty of fluids etc. If it is a dryness issue, you could suck on gummy bears (glycerine) is sometimes helpful, lemon drops or slippery elm lozenges. If it is ongoing, I would get the help of an ENT/Otolaryngologist and a good voice teacher to work on the problem. I would definately not eat vaseline. I'm pretty sure that isn't meant to be eaten.
Amy
on September 5, 2010 2:09pm
Here is another honey trick - learned it from an opera singer. Slowly eat 1 teaspoon of very thick and preferably locally produced honey just prior to singing.
Better tasting and healthier that vaseline but probably serves the same purpose. Lasts about 1 hour, then you have to suffer through another teaspoon!
This trick saved me from having to give up leading my community choir after a bout of bronchitis left me with a spluttering croak.
I only use Manuka honey - but it's very expensive and comes from New Zealand.
on September 6, 2010 6:44am
After you have exhausted all the medical options listed above, try a large amount of REAL maple syrup... the New England kind, the stuff out of the trees, not the commerical pancake stuff... in your choice of hot liquid (coffee, tea, etc.).
on September 9, 2010 7:10am
Yum! I'm down for either one. Any excuse to eat honey and or maple syrup is a good one. I've also heard of singers who take a sliced and peeled apple with them to gigs and eat a few slices before they perform. I'm not sure of the exact science behind eating an apple. I would be a little nervous about eating anything just before I was going to perform. I'd be worried that I'd get a chunk stuck in my throat.
|