Sickness, sinus problems, & crud early in the school yearDate: September 22, 2012 Views: 2212
I live and teach in east central Alabama. Every year waves of sickness wend their way through my college choir as the seasons ebb and flow. Usually the first onslaught is late October, but last year it was early October and this year it has basically begun at the beginning of classes and my singers are going down fast. Headaches, sinus, hoarseness, coughing and subsequent absences are happening early in the semester.
We all know you can't get blood from a stone and when singers are under the weather, their voices are immediatley affected. Does anyone have any scholarly insight on what is causing this so soon and do I have any hope of it improving? My unmedical opinion is that because we had a mild winter last year, allergens weren't killed off as they should have been and so allergy problems are growing.
I also teach applied voice and several of my students cannot sing and we haven't even hit the stress of midterms. I am just marveling in bemused horror how my poor students are suffering! Some valiant students are toughing it out and coming to class but are coughing and hacking during rehearsal and their neighbors are complaning.
Some of my students told me that last week the doctor's hours at the student health center on campus were cancelled because the doctors were sick!
I know there is probably no real solution but I am curious how others may be coping. Any suggestions? Words of comiseration? Homeopathic remedies?
Replies (10): Threaded | Chronological
Eric S Betthauser on September 23, 2012 5:53am
Gargle warm salty water
Use a neti pot at least every other day
Echinacea--though it's best to use for a few weeks, then go off it
Drink some tea brewed with sage when your voice falters
Throat Rescue actually works fairly well
Throat Coat tea is good for a sore throat
When the voice fails, massage the larynx; move it up and down, back and forth;
also, stick your tongue out all the way and stretch it
There is no replacement for LOTS OF SLEEP
on September 23, 2012 1:13pm
We had an uncommonly mild winter here in Chicago, the Land of the Big Snow, and we too have had an early outbreak of the usual maladies. My singers--both of my high sopranos--and my voice students---STREP!--are suffering. I had something in late August, myself, and I rarely get sick at that time of year. I am married to an ENT doc and he has remarked at this as well--so you may well be right about the mild winter.
Our family, via Honey Bunch, is exposed to a LOT of germs and we rarely get sick any more. Why, you may ask? I'll tell you--and I noticed Eric didn't mention this--WE WASH OUR HANDS! We wash our hands when we are around sick people. Hubby washes his hands at work, of course, but I also insist he change his clothes before he takes a nap on our bed or the family room couch. I buy him inexpensive neck ties and he throws them away regularly--he saves the expensive ones when we go out or he visits his mother. And, changing your clothes when you are exposed to sick people sounds a little wacky but after directing a local children's choir for almost a decade, I learned if something was going around, I changed as soon as I got home or I got sick almost every time.
Simple--wash your hands and change your clothes (and throw them in the washer!) when you are around sick people. This will help prevent it going 'round and 'round and 'round!
Marie
on September 23, 2012 4:31pm
This problem occured every fall when I was teaching at a University in the southwest, usually about the third week of the semester. Part of the problem I blamed on the ragweed. Also, many of the students were from northern and eastern states where the air isn't filled with ragweed and other allergens and they experienced allergies, sore throats, sinus problems that had never been an issue for them. My suggestion is that, at least on this campus, the air vents in the dormitories had not been cleaned out for many years, so that when the air conditioning was running, all sorts of allergens, dust, who knows what else.....were being blown into their living space. It's a thought!!!
Marilyn Carver
on September 24, 2012 4:05am
Good ideas here. I also use air purifiers in the rooms where I teach.
(On a related note, I would like to highly commend the Hyatt Regency in Dallas, TX, where I just returned from a conference. They have hypo-allergenic rooms available with air purifiers. Having stayed in many hotel rooms which were full of allergens, I really appreciated the cleanliness of the room and of the air. I hope that more hotels will follow their example.)
on September 24, 2012 7:12am
Here is something I send to my students at the beginning of each semester.
Staying Healthy
Years ago at a convention I heard a presentation (with regret I cannot recall the name of the presenter) that stuck with me because it used the acronym R-E-A-D. In order to stay healthy, you may wish to R-Rest, E-Exercise, A-Attitude, D-Diet.
R – Rest
"Ha! That’s a good one. I am in the School of Music, and I am busy all the time. I don’t have time for rest."
Maybe you don’t have time NOT to rest. Researchers tell us that we need 7-9 hours of sleep per night. Which are you? If you are a 9 hours person, then 7 may not be enough. I read a recent study on sleep deprivation. The volunteers were subjected to various levels of sleep deprivation over a two-week period. Virtually all of the volunteers reported a higher perception of their ability to function while sleep deprived than was actually true. When you are sleep deprived, you don’t think you are impaired. The truth may be that you are much more impaired than you think.
My experience: I remember as an undergraduate doing a reading assignment for history. I looked at the clock, and one hour later I was on page 2! I kept rereading and not comprehending the same page for an hour.
The other “R” for me is re-creation. Do you engage every day in some activity (maybe reading an inspirational book or practicing yoga) to revive your spirit?
E – Exercise
"Ha! That’s another good one. I am in the School of Music, and I don’t have time to exercise."
What exercise does for you is to flood the capillaries with oxygen, energizing your entire body. The exercise program does not need to be strenuous in order to be effective – 45 minutes each day of vigorous walking will do it. You can make your own little “treadmill” by making a circuit around all of the steps in Corthell Hall. Try it once the first time and work up from there. Caveat: Consult your doctor before beginning an exercise program if you have health issues.
My experience: I do not have time not to exercise. I am so much more efficient when I exercise. If I had stopped that undergraduate reading assignment and walked vigorously for 15 minutes, I might have read 15 pages in the next 45 minutes.
My other experience: Getting started is the hardest part. There is a conditioning period of adjustment.
A – Attitude
If I think I am going to hate the history reading assignment, I will. The prophecy will be self-fulfilled. So, I can trick myself by saying, “Oh, good. I get to read history.” Or, I can read the history assignment first, before I practice my instrument – kind of like eating the broccoli before the mashed potatoes.
D – Diet
Yep, what Mom said was true. Too many fats and sweets make me a very dull boy. So, rather than reach for a piece of candy to pick you up while studying (works great until you get the sugar crash later) stop and walk vigorously for 15 minutes. You all know the food pyramid. If you don’t, Google “food pyramid” and find out about healthy eating.
If this semester is true to form, in about 2-4 weeks the accumulated viruses of all of us together will have incubated and about 20% of you will be missing classes. Try to R-E-A-D and see if you can avoid illness. You may not have time to R-E-A-D, but do you have time to be sick and miss classes?
IF you do get sick,
1. Stay home. Get better. You don’t function very well while half-attentive. We don’t want your germs.
2. Rest. Your body needs help to fight the virus.
3. Build your immune system. One way is rest. Another is diet. A third is a multi-vitamin, especially Vitamin C, every day. A fourth is an herbal remedy such as Echinacea.
4. Avoid touching eyes, nose, and mouth – the pathways for viruses to enter.
Keeping a strong immune system is critical. This is likely a genetic issue, but you can influence it as well. The above R-E-A-D suggestions are helpful. For me sugar is the biggest culprit. The more sugar I eat the more depressed I feel, not right away, but certainly in the morning following a heavy evening meal. For some of you the biggest source of sugar – and thus the biggest “hit” to your immune system – may be alcohol.
on September 24, 2012 7:42am
Great points/suggestions.
I would add: Eat a salad with leafy-green vegetables; these fight germs. I add mandarin oranges, or kiwi (has more Vit C than an orange) to sweeten it up, esp. if the greens are a bit bitter. Chicken and/or chicken soup have been shown to actually have medical benefit. Stay off dairy in any form. Many are sensitive to this to this and have no clue. Several articles available on Google suggest that minority populations have a high percentage of dairy sensitivity. Allergies, for anyone, can change dramatically at any time during our life.
Except when the actual vocal folds are affected w/ heavy mucous or dryness, sing "ming," and other "hummy" syllables in the shower. This functions as a natural, no-cost, no-prescription [over-the-choral-counter!?] decongestant. Only side effect is that it improves resonance! ;) But don't do it if the cords are dry, or mucky - obviously that would cause unhealthy pushing.
At home, we keep an old beach towel - the "sick" towel is spread on the couch at the first sign, [on the surface/fabric, to keep it germ-free] until the person is back to functioning without coughing/sneezing - then it is washed in hot water, dried thoroughly at high heat, and stored until the next sickness. Those Northpoint-weave fleece blankets work well to cover a "sick couch" and wash and dry quickly. We have about 7. Another hint that has really lowered our sickness-frequency is washing our toothbrushes w/ disinfectant soap before brushing.
Wash/dust the fans/humidifiers when your energy/health is high - you'll be too tired later, and you'll breathe dust/mold-affected air all night. We put a temporary moratorium on kissing (hugging at waist level subs for this) until the person seems better. (Harsh measures? Not if you realize that "Absence makes the [kiss] grow fonder." )
If some have a strong aversion to garling salt water, plain water usually does pretty well. Also wash the water bottle frequently.
on September 24, 2012 8:26am
Love the "sick towel," Lucy! We throw away our toothbrushes after a bout of sickness....and change them every month or so during the fall and winter......it really does help. There is nothing like good hygine to stop illness. And these are simple things......kids in dorms don't understand why their Moms have been so particular all their lives but will after being in bed with a bad, bad cold.
Marie
on September 24, 2012 11:32am
All people concerned:
Wash hands at every opportunity
Use sinus rinses daily as a preventive: NeilMed Sinus Rinse is easier and quicker for me than neti pot
Drink hot water all day - keep a thermos of it
No sugar
No refined foods - only unprocessed, whole foods
Probiotics and digestive enzymes help get the most nutrition from foods. (I don't recommend the probiotic drinks and yogurts - not strong enough, use super broad spectrum probiotic capsules.)
Salt water gargles are helpful but, full strength Listerine is very effective, too.
on October 19, 2012 4:51pm
Be careful with echinacea if you are allergic to ragweed. That's what it's made of! I found this out the hard way!
Donna
on October 19, 2012 7:43pm
Patricia--since none of us are doctors (of medicine, that is!) I don't suppose you are asking for our health advice! My suggestion is to set a good example. Do what you believe is medically right for you in order to take good care of yourself and be understanding of the students that do the same. I might suggest that the one area teachers do have some control over is the level of stress they add to their students' lives. Not saying that music/choral teachers should give less work than other teachers, but, perhaps it can be given in a way that relieves stress rather than adds to it. After all, music is supposed to be fun. Maybe students who are feeling well enough to come to class but not well enough to sing can sit in the back and listen to the beautiful music :).
|